Home SportsWith 1st-career hat trick in tow, Matthew Schaefer’s legend continues to grow

With 1st-career hat trick in tow, Matthew Schaefer’s legend continues to grow

by Staff Reporter
0 comments

The lengthy list of superlatives for Matthew Schaefer has been exhausted, and the only thing that can properly describe just how transcendental a talent the 19-year-old New York Islanders defenseman is the numbers — though his teammates and coaches will always do their best to properly quantify his impact.

Schaefer recorded the first hat trick of his young career in the Islanders’ 5-1 victory over the Columbus Blue Jackets on Tuesday night at UBS Arena, continuing a blistering start to his second professional season, and breaking a litany of records in the process.

All in a day’s work for the phenom.

Schaefer is the second-youngest defenseman in NHL history to record a hat trick, the first Islanders defenseman to do so since Denis Potvin in 1982, and just the third teenage blue liner in league history to light the lamp three times in a single game.

“I think I was in high school or middle school, maybe,” Islanders head coach Pete DeBoer said. “It’s a long time ago, man. But really impressive.”

The 2025 No. 1 overall pick is currently on a six-game point streak (five goals, five assists, 10 points) and has upped his 2026 totals to nine goals and 15 assists for 24 points in 20 games. 

“We’re watching greatness,” Islanders forward Mathew Barzal said. “If there was a question about the Norris, he’s gotta be right there, if not the front-runner. It’s pretty special. It’s fun to watch, that’s for sure.”

His first goal of the night came at the 1:34 mark of the second period when a loose puck off a scrum fell to him between the circles. Blue Jackets goalie Cam Talbot fell down while trying to get back into position, and Schaefer potted the wrister into the top of the net. 

It was Schaefer’s 30th goal of his career, becoming the youngest defenseman in NHL history (19 years, 126 days) to reach that scoring mark. He was also just the second teenage defenseman in league history to reach 30 goals (Phil Housley). 

“There’s so many great people that have come through this league, and it’s an honor to see that,” Schaefer said. “You really don’t think about that at the end of the day. We’re just worried about what we got going on in this room… All these things, it’s just crazy to hear.”

To put into perspective how rare this kind of scoring is, Schaefer is just the 16th defenseman in franchise history to reach the 30-goal mark, and he’s done so in just 102 games and well before his 20th birthday. 

“It’s a privilege to coach a guy like that,” DeBoer said. “To be able to stand there and watch that every night because he is a generational talent. The people of Long Island are fortunate to have him. I know they know that. He’s a special player, special kid.”

Schaefer’s second of the night at the 7:01 mark of the second period was the perfect embodiment of his natural hockey sense. Defensemen don’t always have the authority to meander down deep into the zone to support the attack, but he’s the exception.

Schaefer pinched down the left boards to keep possession, then stayed down between the circles. Pulock’s shot was kicked right into his path, and his backhand was uncontested.

With 3:52 left in regulation, he capped off his hat trick with an empty-netter, which was set up by Simon Holmstrom, who recorded a hat trick in the Islanders’ previous game, a 6-2 win over the Anaheim Ducks. Schaefer, with both arms stretched high into the air in celebration, leapt into the boards.

“It might’ve been a little too hard of a celly,” Schaefer said. “Maybe I should’ve been a little more respectful with it, but it’s awesome… It’s pretty cool. Just a big win in general.”

This current pace set by Schaefer has been largely unseen by the Islanders. Denis Potvin is the only defenseman in team history who has recorded at least an 80-point season, which he did five times in his illustrious career. 

At this rate, Potvin is going to have some company.

“You saw glimpses of it last year. You see the consistency now,” Barzal said. “I mean, it’s fun to be out there. Throughout my career, it’s been a defensive D-core that I’ve had, which produced good results at times. But to have a factor like that on the back end for the organization. I’ve been saying for a long time how jealous I was of some of these guys throughout the league that played with [Avalanche star Cale] Makar or [Wild defenseman Quinn] Hughes, and we got our guy. So it’s a lot of fun.”

For more on the Islanders and Matthew Schaefer, visit AMNY.com

You may also like

Leave a Comment

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More