Larry Flynt’s Hustler Club has closed after more than 20 years in Hell’s Kitchen and has been replaced by the Peppermint Hippo adult club.
The new club, at 641 West 51st St., between 11th and 12th Avenues, obtained its liquor license in early October, replacing the existing club, which had been licensed under the Hustler name.
“We took it over,” Peppermint Hippo owner Alan Chang said. “The name change hadn’t happened yet. Everything is switched over now.”
Manhattan Community Board 4 recommended against granting a temporary liquor license, unless the club agreed to limit its rooftop bar hours. The club agreed to close its rooftop bar at 2 a.m. nightly, while keeping the indoor club operating until 4 a.m.
Once the New York State Liquor Authority granted the new temporary liquor and business license on Oct. 5, the Hustler club, there since 2004, could no longer operate under its own license. The temporary license is valid through April of next year.
Chang’s ARC Investments NYC and 51st St. Food LLC applied for the license and operate the new club.
“Other than the entity/ownership and trade name changes, this is essentially the same method of operation presented to CB4 by the current tenant/operator at the premise since 2004,” Peppermint Hippo counsel Vivian K. Tozaki wrote in a letter to the board.
Chang’s company signed a 20-year lease for the club from the current building owners, who also licensed the Hustler name and operated the Hustler club.
Community Board 4 did not comment on the area’s new neighbor, despite numerous calls and emails.
Herd of Peppermint Hippos nationwide, with trouble at one
The new Peppermint Hippo in Hell’s Kitchen is part of a chain of seven swanky strip clubs nationwide, including a 27,000-square-foot club in Las Vegas, and three Las Toxicas or “Toxios” clubs.
The odd name “came from South Park,” Chang said of Peppermint Hippo. “If you ever watch South Park, it was a huge joke. They named their adult club in South Park Peppermint Hippo.”
Chang said the location “was already an adult club,” which made it easier for Peppermint Hippo to get its liquor license than strip clubs in virgin locations may have been.
The company’s North Little Rock, AR, Peppermint Hippo club was hit with a $1.16 million wrongful-death verdict after a man in 2021 ejected from the club climbed onto a highway where he was killed by a car.
The club appealed the verdict, which alleged negligence for serving too much alcohol, to the Arkansas Court of Appeals, which has yet to issue a verdict. The Arkansas Alcohol Beverage Control Board this year revoked the Peppermint Hippo’s liquor license at that North Arkansas club, citing violations dating back to the 2021 death.
The club, in its appeal, argued it was being deliberately targeted, citing what it calls private communications between the brother of the man who died and his lawyer and the head of the agency. The board stood by its decision, saying that it alone was responsible for making the call to revoke the liquor license.
The board said the decision was made by the Board itself, not that official, and stands by the decision.
New York City regulations allow for strip clubs to operate in locations in specific commercial and manufacturing districts at sites of under 10,000 sq. ft. They cannot operate within 500 feet of a house of worship, a school, day care centers, residential communities, and other strip clubs.
The Manhattan Peppermint Hippo location is close to public sites such as the Hudson Yards, the Javits Center, the Theater District, and the Manhattan Cruise Terminal.
While the Peppermint Hippo got its license, Manhattan Community Board 4 had opposed efforts to convert a nearby space to an adult club.
W42St.com reported that the Musica nightclub, at West 50th Street and 12th Avenue on the Far West Side, last year sought a zoning variance to add adult entertainment. The board voted against the request in December, citing concerns about “clustering” and proximity to the Hustler Club, W42 St.com reported.
The site indicated the club later withdrew the proposal.
New strip club owner’s New York roots
Chang said he’s originally from Woodside, Queens, but moved to Las Vegas, where he worked for adult clubs after working in other industries. He worked at Sapphire’s and then at the Spearmint Rhino, both in Las Vegas, before opening his first club in Toledo, Ohio, and his first Peppermint Hippo in 2019.
“We did a decent-sized remodeling. We didn’t mess with the construction,” Chang said of the New York Peppermint Hippo. “We basically did an overhaul, made everything up to date, sound, lighting.”
Yet local residents on social media didn’t know what to make of the name.
“Sounds like a tea shop that influencers will flock to,” one said, while another said, “Who goes to strip clubs anymore? It’s on your phone now “
Another said they had their 50th birthday at the Hustler club.
“So they’re closing down one strip joint just to open up another strip joint,” another added.
“It’s only a matter of time till a developer hungers their hands on it and builds a condo,” one more posted.
State of the economy
Adult clubs, Chang said, have been impacted as the economy faces challenges.
“After COVID … Everybody couldn’t go out,” he said. “The economy’s down a little bit.”
Still, he said, business is better at some clubs than others.
“It depends, city by city, location by location,” Chang added. “Younger people are not drinking as much.”
Chang said dancers can work as employees who receive healthcare, or independent contractors. Nearly all choose to be contractors.
“If they’re an employee, they have a shift. They get benefits,” Chang said. “If you’re an independent contractor, you work for yourself.”
He said the club currently does not charge performers, but likely will charge later, as he does at his other clubs.
It’s a zoo out there
If Peppermint Hippo and Spearmint Rhino sound similar to you, that resulted in litigation.
Spearmint Rhino in 2024 in Las Vegas sued Peppermint Hippo over trademark infringement, with the case still active.
Peppermint Hippo is located north of the Spearmint Rhino New York location, which has a rhino as its logo, at 622 West 47th St.
Peppermint Hippo has arrived in Manhattan, but is still awaiting approval to put up a new sign with their logo.
“Nov. 19 is more like a soft opening. We’re really open now,” Chang said as the club awaits the logo that has yet to go up at the entrance. “No one knows we’re really open, but we are.”
