Home New York City15 Years After Complaints to Authorities, Lawsuit Accuses Brooklyn Doctor of Sex Abuse

15 Years After Complaints to Authorities, Lawsuit Accuses Brooklyn Doctor of Sex Abuse

by Staff Reporter
0 comments

More than a decade before three women filed a lawsuit accusing Dr. Richard Grazi, a Brooklyn fertility specialist, of sexually abusing patients, one of the plaintiffs took her allegations to state health officials.

The woman, who asked to remain anonymous, spoke to investigators at the state Department of Health around 2011, she told The City Reporter. 

She recalled being interviewed alongside several other women who also had complaints about Grazi, a prominent physician in her tight-knit Jewish community.

The interview left her believing that state officials were taking the allegations seriously, but months later she was told that, for reasons the department would not explain, no further action was being taken.

“I was deflated,” she recalled, noting she was 19 when she first saw Dr. Grazi. “It’s not something I’d readily share with other people,” she said of her alleged assault. “A person carries a lot of shame.” 

Now, she is among three women suing Grazi, Maimonides Medical Center and Genesis Fertility alleging that the doctor sexually abused them under the guise of medical examinations and that the institutions knew or should have known about his alleged misconduct but failed to protect patients.

The women allege that Grazi exploited his position as a physician to subject them to nonconsensual touching, digital penetration and examinations that served no legitimate medical purpose, according to the lawsuit. They also allege that the examinations were conducted without gloves, a chaperone or appropriate medical staff present. 

Doctor Denies Wrongdoing

Grazi, who has practiced in Brooklyn for decades, has not been charged with a crime and denied any wrongdoing. 

“Dr. Grazi categorically denies the allegations made against him in this lawsuit,” his lawyer, James Nikraftar, told NBC. “Throughout his career, Dr. Grazi has helped thousands of women build their families. He has treated patients with care and professionalism, and that is exactly what the facts will show.”

Tina Lee, a spokesperson for Maimonides, said, “We cannot comment on active litigation, but can confirm that Dr. Richard Grazi is not a Maimonides employee and does not have privileges here.”

Dr. Richard Grazi had served as director of reproductive endocrinology and fertility at Maimonides Medical Center. Credit: Dariusz Gryczka/Shutterstock

Grazi was previously the director of Reproductive Endocrinology and Fertility at Maimonides Medical Center and founded Genesis Fertility and Reproductive Medicine in Bensonhurst. The clinic, which specializes in IVF and egg freezing, was popular among members of the Jewish community. 

Grazi’s medical license remains active, according to state Health Department records. 

The state health commissioner has the power to suspend a doctor from practicing pending the conclusion of an investigation if that person poses an imminent danger. 

But that rarely happens. 

MORE: A 27-Hour Wait for a Hospital Bed? Why Delays Are Growing at New York Hospitals

Patient advocates have long criticized state medical boards for allowing doctors who are under scrutiny to continue to practice while under investigation. The boards usually are heavily made up of doctors nominated by state and local medical societies.

Erin Clary, a Health Department spokesperson, said the state takes “all allegations of medical misconduct seriously” and follows guidelines laid out by state law. The department is prohibited from discussing any investigation, complaint, or prosecution beyond what is published on its website, she added. 

A 2025 Newsday investigation found that the state’s system for disciplining doctors had become increasingly lenient, with serious disciplinary actions declining even as the number of physicians practicing in New York grew.

The state received at least 7,900 complaints annually between 2013 and 2023, but took no more than 440 final actions in any year, according to the report. 

Newsday also found that the rate of serious disciplinary actions fell by roughly half over the decade ending in 2023.

Eileen Corina, founder and president of Pulse Center for Patient Safety Education & Advocacy, said the case highlights how vulnerable patients can be when they seek medical care, especially when they don’t know what to expect during an examination or where to turn if a doctor crosses a line.

The three women suing Grazi asked to remain anonymous because of the sensitive nature of the allegations.

‘Inappropriate Behavior’ Alleged in 2005 Lawsuit

The complaint alleges that Maimonides and the Genesis Fertility knew or should have known of concerning conduct years earlier because of a 2005 lawsuit filed by former physician Dr. Susan M. Lobel, who worked with Dr. Grazi. 

That lawsuit, which primarily focused on a labor dispute, also alleged “inappropriate behavior with female patients and staff.”

Dr. Lobel did not respond to a call and text message seeking comment. 

More women have come forward alleging similar abuses since the lawsuit was filed, according to Helene Weiss, who is representing the three plaintiffs. They are considering joining the litigation, Weiss said. 

Those women “could have been spared abuse if only the institutions around him had listened years ago,” Weiss told The City Reporter. 

Fifteen years after first bringing her allegations to state investigators, the former patient is hoping her lawsuit will bring accountability.

“The doctor should not have a medical license,” she said, “and should not be around women and children.”

Our nonprofit newsroom relies on donations from readers to sustain our local reporting and keep it free for all New Yorkers. Donate to THE CITY today.

The post 15 Years After Complaints to Authorities, Lawsuit Accuses Brooklyn Doctor of Sex Abuse appeared first on The City Reporter.

You may also like

Leave a Comment

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More